Fillmore woman charged with stealing over $22K from church, North Andrew Booster Club

ANDREW COUNTY, Mo. (KQTV) -- A Fillmore, Missouri, woman is facing felony theft and fraudulent use charges after she allegedly stole over $22,000 from the North Andrew Booster Club and First Baptist Church combined.

Sarah E. Roller, 54, allegedly utilized numerous fraudulent and unauthorized credit cards from July 14, 2024, and July 14, 2026.

According to a probable cause statement, a total of $19,597.29 was utilized on First Baptist Church credit cards. Roller admitted to the unauthorized use for her own personal gain.

"It should be noted, Sarah E. Roller has extensive criminal history for stealing," the statement said.

Another probable cause statement detailed that Roller had access to a North Andrew Booster Club debit card through Nodaway Valley Bank assigned to her.

From Aug. 1, 2023, to April 29, 2026, Roller used the debit card to make unauthorized purchases in Andrew County totalling $2,546.98.